Op-Ed: The Goal of Zoning is to Stop Reasonably priced Housing

Op-Ed: The Goal of Zoning is to Stop Reasonably priced Housing

I strongly help the Simplifying Codes for Reasonably priced Improvement (SCAD) textual content amendments to Durham’s zoning code. I helped provoke SCAD and assume its small-scale modifications to the zoning code will assist result in extra small-lot housing, extra neighborhood-scale retail, extra mixed-use initiatives, extra renters who can turn into house owners, and extra Lacking Center Housing. It’ll additionally assist Durham turn into a extra walkable, much less car dependent, friendlier, and extra attention-grabbing place to reside.  

Bob Chapman

That is the third time up to now 25 years that I sponsored or cosponsored code amendments. 4 years in the past, I used to be a part of the crew of small-scale growth practitioners who helped carry the profitable Expanded Housing Selections (EHC) amendments. The small lot reforms we initiated in 2019 bent the curve. Regardless of being the tightest market within the Triangle, the Bull Metropolis has 28 new properties below $400,000 presently on the market in the marketplace. Raleigh has one. Chapel Hill has zero. These reforms, led by Mayor Steve Schewel, have resurrected starter-home markets which are in any other case non-existent within the Triangle’s three cities.

In 1998, Duke College requested me to construct a brand new neighborhood on eight vacant acres they owned behind East Campus. As a brand new urbanist, I needed to construct a neighborhood that maintained the architectural character of its setting, however that turned out to be unlawful. I needed to introduce 12 code amendments to have the ability to construct on smaller heaps, to retain and construct the platted alleys, to construct single-family homes near the road, to construct townhouses that didn’t attempt to appear to be particular person homes glued collectively, and even to plant avenue bushes on the street tree planter strip between the curb and the sidewalk. Then, with these 12 amendments, we had been informed that our plan was nonetheless unlawful: It was 20 % denser than the principles allowed. 

Fortuitously, our planning director, presumably with a wink and a nod, declared that if the present streets had been referred to as “buffer areas,” he would rule that we had been a “suburban cluster subdivision” and certified for a 20 % density bonus. From that have, I realized what a ridiculous impediment course awaited anybody making an attempt to do one thing that didn’t align with the rulebook.  

Once I got here to Durham as a university pupil in 1965, Durham’s zoning code was 23 pages lengthy. Compact walkable growth wasn’t outlawed. The truth is, the Durham code permitted “70 households per acre” in Trinity Park. (Consequently, Trinity Park nonetheless has much-admired and sought-after multi-family house buildings “grandfathered in” on practically each block.)

Then, the world modified.

On April 4, 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated.  

On April 11, 1968, Congress handed the Honest Housing Act. It outlawed discrimination primarily based on race, faith, and nationwide origin within the sale, rental, and financing of housing. It appeared that America’s custom of outright housing discrimination was now not authorized.  

However communities rapidly discovered a workaround, not solely within the South however nationwide: Racial segregation may very well be maintained implicitly, if not explicitly. All a metropolis needed to do was down-zone. Aggressive down-zoning befell throughout America and throughout Durham, particularly in prosperous neighborhoods. The bottom zoning for the center of Trinity Park was modified from 70 items per acre to eight.  

For extra info, please learn Richard Rothstein’s groundbreaking guide The Coloration of Regulation, which particulars how municipalities throughout America deliberately preserved racial segregation via their zoning codes. Or seek the advice of M. Nolan Grey’s guide Arbitrary Strains: How Zoning Broke the American Metropolis and Easy methods to Repair It, which supplies extra specifics and presents options.

Inside 11 months of the enactment of the Honest Housing Act, the dimensions of Durham’s zoning code elevated by 1,300 %, efficiently codifying financial discrimination as an efficient substitute for racial discrimination. The creation of latest inexpensive housing was successfully outlawed in all of Durham’s extra prosperous neighborhoods.  

In the present day, Durham’s land-use laws fill greater than 2,300 dense pages. It’s turn into a chunky Keep-Puft Marshmallow Man that gobbles up regulatory frontiers as quick as it might assume them up.  

It additionally hindered the Black group’s means to rebuild itself.  

What occurred?  

The Honest Housing Act accompanied federal Mannequin Cities and City Renewal applications that destroyed giant swaths of Durham’s Hayti neighborhood in addition to the beating coronary heart of the Black group—the Pettigrew Avenue business district. The injury was irreparable. It stays so even at present. 

The worst elements of this urbicide had been embedded within the zoning code. In the present day’s code basically displays the identical set of values because the racist code that was applied in 1969. It’s constructed on the hallmarks of recent planning discrimination, together with density maximums, parking mandates, and extremely advanced allowing laws with unpredictable and arbitrary outcomes which are so costly to barter that enormous nationwide builders with deep pockets have an enormous benefit over often smaller native practitioners.  

The excellent news is that Durham has been transferring in the proper route. 4 years in the past, Metropolis Council directed our planning division to ask a bunch of smaller-scale native builders to debate with them what was stopping the development of extra inexpensive housing. I used to be a member of this practitioners’ panel. It collaboratively labored with the town to provide the zoning code amendments included in Increasing Housing Selections (EHC), which lowered minimal lot sizes and eradicated single-family zoning in central Durham.

Zoning has an extended historical past of discrimination that continues at present. Lisa Prevost’s guide Snob Zones: Concern, Prejudice, and Actual Property paperwork how suburban communities use zoning to exclude poor individuals, minorities, the younger, and middle-class households. Zoning permits “not-in-my-backyard” NIMBYs to require that authorities planning departments implement NIMBY prejudices. This isn’t a coincidence. Stopping inexpensive housing has lengthy been a main goal of zoning. 

The individuals lobbying to forestall zoning reform at present additionally search to forestall inexpensive housing, significantly close to them. It’s not new. NIMBY teams will in all probability at all times exist, however they’re on the incorrect facet of historical past. For instance, earlier this 12 months, Congress enacted and President Biden signed ten particular “yes-in-my-backyard” (YIMBY) provisions with funding for municipalities that take away obstacles to inexpensive housing from their zoning codes. Final week, the Washington State Home of Representatives handed a invoice that might get rid of single-family zoning and legalize duplexes and four-plexes in nearly each metropolis statewide. The query is: How does Durham take care of the anti-affordable housing provisions embedded in our personal codes? 

Zoning reform is perpetually vital as a result of codes are so extremely advanced, and practitioners are continually studying new issues. Frontline suggestions must be processed into higher codes and, finally, a greater high quality of life for all. 

Durham is in a singular place to guide right here. The small lot reforms in 2019 could have bent the curve, however there’s at all times extra to do. There are methods to make these small-lot properties higher. Market suggestions is displaying that the zoning code requires driveways to be too giant and thus undesirable. Gutter necessities depart builders unable to take care of downspouts in cheap methods. Parking mandates flip what might have been good courtyards into unneeded (and undesirable) parking heaps. All are simply fixable via easy reforms.

SCAD reforms put money into the imaginative and prescient of a greater metropolis. The Japanese name it Kaizen—perpetual enchancment. There isn’t a excellent. There isn’t a finish. There may be simply fixed studying and betterment. The post-1969 code was so unhealthy, it would take 60-plus years to steam clear it. EHC was a begin, SCAD is one other step, and our planning director Sara Younger’s Unified Improvement Ordinance (UDO) rewrite over the subsequent few years ought to enhance it additional nonetheless. It’ll by no means be accomplished. Cities by no means are. However the work should proceed, and reform is inherent to that mission. Zoning exists to discriminate, and Durham doesn’t. That’s why reform is critical.

Bob Chapman lives in Durham and is concerned in group initiatives together with creating inexpensive housing and walkable neighborhoods.

Touch upon this story at [email protected].

Assist impartial native journalism

Be a part of the INDY Press Membership to assist us preserve fearless watchdog reporting and important arts and tradition protection viable within the Triangle.