Invoice 23 weakens heritage safety: heritage group, city planner say

Invoice 23 weakens heritage safety: heritage group, city planner say

Article content material

Saugeen Shores heritage advocates are warning that Ontario’s Invoice 23 threatens greater than 100 heritage buildings within the city by weakening their already modest protections.

Commercial 2

Article content material

The Southampton Cultural Heritage Conservancy has filed objections to heritage provisions in Invoice 23, the Extra Houses Sooner Act, saying it might trigger Saugeen Shores to lose heritage safety for a lot of of its important heritage buildings.

Architectural Conservancy Ontario’s chair, Diane Chin, has known as the proposed laws “a cluster bomb” that “is not going to create a single unit of reasonably priced housing.”

“This will solely be seen as a knee jerk response to a vindictive assault by the event trade on our heritage system,” she stated in a information launch, including there was no session.

The not-for-profit Southampton heritage group differed with the municipality previously few years over a allow the city issued to demolish the previous St. Paul’s Anglican rectory in Southampton, one thing a decide has since ordered should not occur.

Commercial 3

Article content material

The city of Saugeen Shores had beforehand declined to undertake a suggestion from its heritage committee to listing it as a heritage property. Additional, there hasn’t been a property designated underneath the Ontario Heritage Act within the amalgamated group of Saugeen Shores because it was created greater than 20 years in the past, stated native conservancy member Sheila Latham, who co-authored the Invoice 23 submission, in an interview.

However concerning Invoice 23, the group agrees with Saugeen Shores’ supervisor of growth providers, Jay Pausner, who’s recommending in a report back to council that the city object to adjustments to the Ontario Heritage Act.

The city’s heritage registry contains 122 properties of “cultural heritage significance,” together with church buildings, properties, lighthouses and parks in Saugeen Shores, and 12 provincially “designated” buildings, each personal and public.

Commercial 4

Article content material

The proposed laws requires all municipally listed heritage properties to satisfy extra stringent provincial requirements of designation underneath the Ontario Heritage Act or they’d drop off the listing inside two years. As soon as off, they will’t return for 5 years.

House owners of listed properties should notify the municipality in the event that they plan to demolish the property 60 days beforehand, fairly than the same old 10 days earlier than. That’s the one safety itemizing gives.

Nevertheless it indicators the property is “to be prevented” by builders, the heritage group’s submission says. By mechanically dropping listed properties from municipal heritage registries after two years, heritage properties “will lose the slight safety that itemizing gives . . .”

Commercial 5

Article content material

Following “prescribed standards” would make designating properties “impractical, labour-intensive, and expensive.” Saugeen Shores doesn’t have employees devoted to heritage preservation and Invoice 23 provides no new funding, the submission says.

Additional, requiring a property to satisfy a couple of designation standards, as Chin on the Architectural Conservancy of Ontario says would consequence, would seemingly exclude the “humble dwelling of Saugeen Metis herbalist Angelique Longe . . . But the long-lasting ‘Aunt Annie’ stays among the many greatest identified historic figures in Southampton,” the Southampton group says.

“The amendments would consequence not in additional properties, however in an equal variety of trendy, much less reasonably priced properties.”

“The unfavourable impacts would come with a considerable lack of heritage character, lack of distinctive identification, and harm to the tourism economic system of Southampton, which markets itself as ‘the oldest port on the Bruce.’”

Commercial 6

Article content material

The submission additionally takes situation with Invoice 23’s proposal to eradicate from municipal management over issues of exterior design.

The submission says Saugeen Shores initiatives a 1,330 surplus of residential items over the subsequent 25 years, which makes weakening heritage protections “fully pointless . . .”

Pausner, the Saugeen Shores planner, says in his report that Invoice 23 will “have an effect on how municipalities establish and shield cultural heritage properties.”

“Adjustments will imply heritage registers will must be reviewed and properties designated, and if not designated, should be faraway from the registry.”

He argues Invoice 23’s adjustments threaten to restrict the municipality’s potential to guard and protect the architectural allure of small cities. Invoice 23 will seemingly trigger the city’s heritage registry of vital cultural heritage properties to be dissolved, the report stated.

Commercial 7

Article content material

And given lower than one per cent of the city’s properties are on its heritage registry, dissolving the registry received’t have a big “or most likely any” affect on rising the availability of housing, he wrote.

One other downside is “prescriptive necessities” for designating heritage districts — a course of proposed to be embarked upon in 2023 in Saugeen Shores — which “could encumber how the city needs to protect its present character.

“It is vital for native communities to have flexibility in figuring out what’s vital to rejoice the city’s cultural and constructed heritage . . .” Pausner’s report says.

To be listed, “properties will now be evaluated underneath a set of provincially prescribed requirements,” not but outlined, Pausner wrote.

Commercial 8

Article content material

The explanation for the present 60 days’ discover of intention to demolish listed properties is to purchase time for the municipality to designate the construction, Pausner’s report says. He notes Saugeen Shores’ Municipal Heritage Committee doesn’t listing a property if the proprietor doesn’t approve. However that 60-day ready interval nonetheless permits time for others to rearrange for the constructing to be moved and reused, together with as reasonably priced housing, which has occurred a lot of instances, the report stated.

Some heritage properties have been acknowledged due to their architectural magnificence, the report stated, however “most significantly, all of those properties have contributed not directly to the cultural, social and financial growth of our group.” The registry contains particulars about who constructed the heritage properties and contribution to the event of the city.

“And, from a purely financial perspective, the commemoration of heritage buildings in Saugeen Shores and different smaller municipalities helps to protect the normal character and allure of our cities, attributes which magnetize vacationers, householders and companies to spend money on our financial future.”

Commercial 1


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We now have enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail when you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra info and particulars on how you can alter your e-mail settings.